Queens, January 11, 2026
A legal conflict has arisen at New Yorker Wholesale Bagels, following the death of co-founder George Menegatos. His sons allege betrayal and mismanagement by Nicholas Evangelinos’ family, leading to a lawsuit seeking $25 million in damages. The case underscores the challenges faced by family-owned businesses regarding succession planning and asset distribution, potentially affecting the company’s future operations and ownership structure.
Legal Dispute Erupts at New Yorker Wholesale Bagels in Queens
The aftermath of co-founder George Menegatos’ death raises questions about succession and trust.
New York City – A legal dispute has emerged within the New Yorker Wholesale Bagels company, a prominent Queens-based bagel producer with annual sales of approximately $50 million. The conflict centers on allegations of betrayal and mismanagement following the death of co-founder George Menegatos in March 2021.
According to a lawsuit filed in Brooklyn Federal Court, George’s son, Spiro Menegatos, and his brother, Steven, claim that Nicholas Evangelinos’ son, Stefanos Evangelinos, has excluded them from the business. The Menegatos brothers allege that Stefanos denied them their father’s company shares, which were intended to pass to them under a 2016 shareholder agreement signed by George and Stefanos. The lawsuit seeks $25 million in damages.
Background of New Yorker Wholesale Bagels
New Yorker Wholesale Bagels, established in the 1980s by George Menegatos and Nicholas Evangelinos, has grown into a significant player in the bagel industry, supplying approximately 100 million bagels annually. The company operates a factory in Long Island City, Queens, and is known for its fresh, hand-rolled bagels delivered to various establishments across the New York area. This entrepreneurial success exemplifies how small businesses can thrive in a competitive market, creating jobs and community ties.
The Allegations at Hand
The Menegatos family has asserted that Stefanos, who was George’s 50/50 partner and was considered the point person for New Yorker Bagels, exploited the trust placed in him. They claim that after George’s passing, Stefanos falsely maintained that the company operated solely on a “handshake” arrangement, neglecting the formal agreement that clearly entitles the Menegatos brothers to shares of the company.
Understanding the Legal Implications
The lawsuit highlights the potential complexities and conflicts that can arise in family-owned businesses, particularly concerning succession planning. The Menegatos brothers’ claims indicate significant rifts that could impact the company’s operational future and ownership structure. As a business that has contributed vastly to New York’s economy, the ramifications of this dispute may reverberate beyond the courtroom, affecting employees and suppliers alike.
Family Business Dynamics
Family-owned businesses are often built on trust and shared history. However, without clear succession plans and formal agreements, such businesses can quickly descend into conflict. New Yorker Wholesale Bagels serves as a reminder of the importance of legal frameworks in ensuring smooth transitions and protecting all stakeholders involved. The outcome of this lawsuit could potentially underscore the necessity for rigorous regulatory support to bolster family business continuity.
Conclusion
The developments surrounding New Yorker Wholesale Bagels present a clarion call for family businesses to prioritize succession planning and formal agreements. As New York continues to foster a vibrant tapestry of entrepreneurial spirit, community-minded leaders and investors must advocate for balanced regulations that protect both individuals and the broader economic environment. Supporting local businesses and engaging with their stories might be critical not only to their survival but also to the economic vitality of New York City.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the nature of the lawsuit involving New Yorker Wholesale Bagels?
The lawsuit alleges that Stefanos Evangelinos, son of co-founder Nicholas Evangelinos, excluded the Menegatos brothers from the business and denied them their father’s company shares, despite a 2016 shareholder agreement.
What is the value of New Yorker Wholesale Bagels?
The company has annual sales of approximately $50 million and supplies about 100 million bagels each year.
What is the history of New Yorker Wholesale Bagels?
Established in the 1980s by George Menegatos and Nicholas Evangelinos, the company has grown into a significant player in the bagel industry, operating a factory in Long Island City, Queens.
What are the potential implications of this lawsuit?
The lawsuit may affect the future operations and ownership structure of New Yorker Wholesale Bagels, highlighting challenges in family-owned businesses regarding succession planning and asset distribution.
Key Features of the Article
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Legal Dispute | Allegations of betrayal and mismanagement following the death of co-founder George Menegatos in March 2021. |
| Company Overview | New Yorker Wholesale Bagels, established in the 1980s, has annual sales of approximately $50 million and supplies about 100 million bagels each year. |
| Implications | The lawsuit may affect the future operations and ownership structure of the company, highlighting challenges in family-owned businesses regarding succession planning and asset distribution. |
Now Happening on X
- @nypost (Jan 10, 2026): Reports on the lawsuit against a NYC bagel dynasty with $50 million sales, alleging betrayal by a business partner. View on X
- @nypmetro (Jan 10, 2026): Highlights the legal dispute schmeared by betrayal in the NYC bagel business lawsuit. View on X
- @cheynne081 (Jan 10, 2026): Shares an exclusive article on the NYC bagel dynasty lawsuit involving $50 million sales and partner betrayal. View on X
- @uhzman (Jan 11, 2026): Expresses sadness over children of founders getting greedy and cutting off others in family businesses. View on X
- @podbing (Jan 3, 2026): Discusses a family business lawsuit where the family’s stakes are high, with the mother’s life hanging in the balance. View on X
- @CoffiStop (Jan 8, 2026): Covers a lawsuit by Uncle Nearest owners suing their ex-CFO for fraud and abuse of power in a family-owned business. View on X
- @SneakerLegal (Jan 8, 2026): Notes a settlement in a trademark infringement lawsuit between DC bagel shops Call Your Mother and Call Your Bubbi. View on X
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Author: STAFF HERE NEW YORK WRITER
The NEW YORK STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERENewYork.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in New York, the five boroughs, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as New York Fashion Week, Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, and Tribeca Film Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Greater New York Chamber of Commerce and United Way of New York, plus leading businesses in finance and media that power the local economy such as JPMorgan Chase, Goldman Sachs, and Bloomberg. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREBuffalo.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into New York's dynamic landscape.
