September 23, 2025

Man Denied Service at Café Grumpy for Wearing MAGA Hat

News Summary

A man was denied service at Café Grumpy in NYC due to his red ‘Make America Great Again’ hat while attending a memorial for his father on September 11. The incident raised questions about political expression and service refusal based on appearance. After confronting the barista for an explanation, the man was eventually served. Café co-founder condemned the incident and confirmed that a disciplinary action was taken against the barista involved.

New York City – A 31-year-old man from New Jersey, Anthony Pullis, was denied service at Café Grumpy in the Financial District on September 11 while wearing a red “Make America Great Again” hat. This incident occurred as Pullis was on his way to attend a memorial ceremony at Ground Zero in honor of his late father, who was killed in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001.

Pullis had a photo of his deceased father, Edward Pullis, pinned to his shirt pocket and typically refrains from wearing the MAGA hat on that significant day out of respect for the victims. However, he made the decision to wear it to show support for conservative activist Charlie Kirk, who had been murdered the day before.

Upon entering the café, Pullis attempted to place an order but was met with a refusal from the barista, who stated, “No service.” Initially believing that the café might not be open, Pullis checked the posted hours and observed that other patrons were being served. This led him to suspect that his hat was the reason for being denied service.

Accompanied by his friend Michael Antonucci, Pullis considered leaving but felt compelled to confront the situation. He was driven by a sense of duty and a desire to stand firm, especially in light of the circumstances surrounding Kirk’s assassination. After leaving the café, Pullis returned with Tommy Smith, a retired firefighter and family friend, to demand service.

The barista ultimately complied but did not provide an explanation for the initial refusal. As Pullis paid for his $14 order, he opted to leave a $20 tip. Yet, as he departed, the barista called him “disgusting.” Following the incident, Pullis and his family shared their experiences through Google reviews.

Café Grumpy co-founder Caroline Bell expressed horror over the incident and indicated that disciplinary action had been taken against the barista involved. Bell affirmed that company policy prohibits denial of service based on appearance or personal beliefs. Pullis later acknowledged Bell’s professionalism in addressing the issue but criticized the barista’s behavior, particularly given the significance of September 11.

As of now, Café Grumpy has not responded to immediate inquiries concerning the incident. The story has been reported widely, gaining attention across social media and various news platforms.

Background Context

The events of September 11, 2001, mark a significant and somber date in American history, as it commemorates the lives lost during the terrorist attacks. The MAGA hat has become a symbol associated with former President Donald Trump and conservative political beliefs. This incident raises discussions about political expression and the consequences individuals may face based on their attire in public spaces.