News Summary
New York lawmakers are considering a bill that would allow grocery stores to sell wine, raising concerns among local liquor store owners about potential negative impacts. The proposed legislation aims to enhance shopping convenience and promote New York wines, but local retailers fear it could threaten their businesses. With sales of wine constituting a significant portion of their revenues, liquor store owners worry that they won’t be able to compete with larger grocery chains. The bill’s fate remains uncertain as discussions continue on balancing market access with the protection of small businesses.
New York lawmakers are currently evaluating a bill that proposes allowing grocery stores to sell wine, a move that has raised concerns among local liquor store owners about potential negative impacts on their businesses. The proposed legislation, spearheaded by New York State Senator Liz Krueger, aims to enhance shopping convenience while promoting wines produced in New York State.
If passed, the legislation, known as State Senate Bill S1279A, would permit grocery chains such as Weis Markets and Price Chopper to offer wine alongside traditional grocery items. This change is a significant shift from current regulations that restrict wine sales to licensed liquor outlets only.
The owner of Vestal Wine and Liquor, Mark Darpino, who has been operating his store for nearly 35 years, is among those voicing apprehensions about the bill. He notes that wine accounts for a substantial portion of sales at his liquor store, representing approximately 50-60% of his total revenues. Darpino has already experienced a 10% decline in sales in recent years, which he attributes to changes in drinking habits among younger consumers.
Darpino warns that allowing grocery stores to sell wine will further decrease sales for small liquor retailers like his, potentially jeopardizing their ability to compete in the market. While the legislation intends to make New York wines more accessible, Darpino expresses skepticism, noting that larger grocery stores are likely to prioritize stocking only well-known brands, to the detriment of small vineyards that local liquor stores actively promote.
He emphasizes the important role that independent liquor stores play in supporting small New York wineries, asserting that if these small businesses close due to decreased sales, fewer retailers will be available to carry and promote these local products. This could undermine the very goal of showcasing New York’s wine industry, which the bill aims to achieve.
Furthermore, the conversation surrounding the bill has raised broader concerns about potential job losses and further deregulation of alcohol sales in the state. Ean Darpino, Mark’s son, voiced fears that if the bill is enacted, it could set a precedent for allowing grocery stores to sell liquor in the future. Such a change would pose significant risks to neighborhood liquor stores and their employees.
Despite these concerns, proponents of the bill argue that wine sales in grocery stores could stimulate the economy and improve overall consumer convenience. They cite examples from other states, like Florida, where liquor stores have continued to thrive alongside grocery store wine sales. Advocates believe that increased access to wine will benefit consumers looking for a one-stop shopping experience and provide better visibility for New York wineries.
As the review process for State Senate Bill S1279A continues within a committee of the New York State Senate, the fate of this legislation remains uncertain. The discussions surrounding the bill highlight a significant debate about the balance between enhancing market access and protecting small businesses in the state’s liquor industry. Lawmakers will need to weigh the potential economic benefits against the possible repercussions for local liquor stores as they consider this pivotal legislation.
The outcome of this proposal could reshape the alcohol sales landscape in New York, with implications not only for consumers but also for the livelihoods of small business owners who have long depended on a more restrictive framework for alcohol distribution in the state.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
- WBNG: NY Lawmakers Propose Selling Wine in Grocery Stores
- Press Connects: Pat Price Obituary
- WNBH: Rouhana Vestal Missing
- WICZ: Teacher of the Week – Laurie Tait
- Stupid Dope: Diamond Frosted Infused Flower Restocked in Vestal
- Wikipedia: Wine
- Google Search: Wine in Grocery Stores
