New York State Upholds Law Moving Local Elections to Even-Numbered Years

News Summary

New York state has confirmed a significant change in local election scheduling, moving many elections to even-numbered years to align with state and federal contests. The ruling by a state appeals court overturned a previous decision declaring the law unconstitutional, despite challenges from local governments fearing it undermines their electoral authority. Proponents argue that this will enhance voter turnout, while opponents worry local issues could be overshadowed. The legal battle is expected to escalate to New York’s highest court, reflecting ongoing debates about local governance and state control.

New York state has affirmed a significant legislative change regarding the scheduling of local elections. On May 7, 2025, a state appeals court upheld a law that moves many local elections to even-numbered years, aligning them with state and federal elections. This ruling reverses a previous decision by a lower court that had declared the law unconstitutional in the fall of 2024.

The law, which applies to various local elections outside New York City, notably excludes elections for county clerk, sheriff, district attorneys, and local judges, which are shielded by the state Constitution. The legal challenges were primarily spearheaded by Republican-led groups in Onondaga County, who argued that the law violated local charters and deprived counties of their rights to govern their electoral processes.

The appeals court found that while the state constitution allows local governments to elect legislative bodies, it does not grant them exclusive authority over the conduct of elections. There are currently twenty counties in New York that are constitutionally chartered, having their laws created and approved locally to dictate their operations.

This law, originally passed by the New York state Legislature and signed into effect by Governor Kathy Hochul in December 2023, faced scrutiny from several counties. The appeal argued against the classification of the law as a “general law,” but the court ruled that it is applicable uniformly across all counties outside of New York City.

Supporters of the law believe it will increase voter turnout in local elections, as larger state and federal races traditionally attract more voters. They argue that synchronizing local elections with these broader contests will foster a more inclusive and representative democratic process. Conversely, opponents fear that local issues may be drowned out by the more high-profile state and national campaigns, potentially disenfranchising local voters.

In response to the ruling, Onondaga County Legislature Chairman expressed his disappointment and signaled intentions to escalate the appeal to New York’s highest court. The ruling, if upheld, could result in shorter terms for candidates elected during the upcoming November 2025 elections.

Additionally, eight counties, including Rockland, Orange, Dutchess, and Oneida, have also challenged the law, with some announcing plans to appeal the most recent ruling as well. Rising discontent has been voiced among county officials, particularly in Rockland County, where officials argue that the law violates their local charter and undermines the rights of voters to determine how and when to elect their representatives.

The next step in this legal dispute will take place at the Court of Appeals, New York’s highest judicial authority. The ongoing challenges reflect a broader conversation about local governance and electoral integrity, raising questions about the balance of power between state mandates and local rights.

This case highlights the complexities surrounding electoral law in New York, encapsulating the tensions between local autonomy and state control. As the judicial process unfolds, the implications for future local elections remain a significant concern for many stakeholders across the state.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

• Spectrum Local News
• Wikipedia: Elections in New York
• Record Online
• Google Search: New York election law
• Finger Lakes 1
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Election
• ABC News
• Google News: New York even year election law