New York Appeals Court Upholds Local Election Law

News Summary

A New York state appeals court has upheld a law shifting local elections to even-numbered years, countering a prior ruling that deemed it unconstitutional. The law, signed by Governor Kathy Hochul, impacts 20 counties and aims to boost voter turnout by aligning these elections with state and federal contests. However, critics worry about local issues being overshadowed by broader topics in high-stakes elections. The decision marks a crucial moment in the ongoing legal dialogue regarding local governance and electoral processes in New York.

New York – A New York state appeals court has upheld the constitutionality of a law that shifts local elections to even-numbered years. This decision marks a significant development after a lower court’s ruling in fall 2023 that had previously declared the law unconstitutional. The appeals court ruling came as a response to challenges led by Republicans, who argued that the law contradicted individual county charters.

The legislation impacts 20 counties across New York that operate under charters, which are locally drafted laws that dictate governance structures. The court’s ruling emphasized the state constitution’s provision, which supports local governments having a “legislative body elective by the people.” This provision plays a crucial role in reinforcing the legality of the new election schedule.

Governor Kathy Hochul signed the law in December 2023, mandating that elections for various local offices, excluding New York City, will now coincide with even-numbered years. Notably, there are exceptions for certain city or village elections and roles safeguarded by the state constitution, such as those for county clerks, sheriffs, district attorneys, and judges.

The challenges originated in Onondaga County, where opponents contended that the statute does not qualify as a “general law” since its reach does not encompass all counties uniformly, particularly those entirely contained within cities, towns, or villages. However, the appeals court countered that the law’s application to counties outside New York City meets the criteria of a general law, upholding its enforceability.

The court also examined various constitutional arguments posed by the challengers but found them to be without merit. With the court’s decision, advocates for the law believe that synchronizing local elections with state and federal elections could significantly enhance voter turnout. This is due to the expectation that voters may be more likely to participate in elections when they coincide with more prominent state and national contests.

Despite the positive outlook from supporters, concerns have been raised regarding the potential overshadowing of local issues by broader state and national topics that dominate even-numbered year ballots. Critics argue that this shift could dilute the focus on community-centric issues, making it harder for local candidates to engage effectively with voters.

Following the appeals court ruling, the challengers still have the option to escalate the matter to New York’s highest court, which could bring further developments to this ongoing legal narrative surrounding local elections in the state.

This case embodies a larger conversation about the balance of local and state governance and the implications of election timing on voter engagement. As the legal battle potentially progresses to higher courts, the impact of this ruling may ultimately shape the future of local electoral processes across New York State.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

• City and State NY: Endorsements 2025 New York City Mayoral Race
• Politico: Airbnb is a Big Player in This Year’s Local Elections
• Democracy Docket: New York Republicans Sue the State Over Law to Move All Local Elections to Even Years
• Insurance Journal: New York Local Elections Update
• New York Times: UK Local Elections Results
• Wikipedia: Local Elections in the United States
• Google Search: New York 2025 Elections
• Google Scholar: Local Elections New York
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Elections
• Google News: New York Election Lawsuit